Sisterhood Sleuths

I didn’t expect to read this in one sitting, but The Obsidian Eye pulled me in like a magnet. From the moment Chloe and Lily stumbled across the strange artifact, it felt like opening a secret compartment in an otherwise normal day. There’s no slow climb—it’s like you’ve already been dropped into the puzzle and the clock is ticking.

What makes this book shine is the sibling bond. Chloe’s boldness and Lily’s calm intellect balance each other perfectly. It felt less like reading characters and more like watching real sisters bounce off each other under pressure, and it kept me emotionally invested.

There’s a strong mystery at the center of the story, and the clues unfold in a way that keeps you guessing—but never confused. Warshaw doesn’t hand anything to you, which makes solving things alongside the girls really satisfying.

I was also impressed by how well the secondary characters were used. No one felt like set dressing; each person added tension or insight, helping to raise the stakes without overcomplicating the plot.

Short but tightly written, The Obsidian Eye is a thrilling start to what feels like a very promising series. I’m already hoping for the sequel.

Richa (Goodreads)